Type: Analysis · Author: Hard Signal Newsroom · Dates of events: 2015 (Garland, Texas attack), November 6, 2026 (Ninth Circuit ruling)

What the court actually did

On November 6, 2026, a divided Ninth Circuit panel (2-1) reversed Abdul Malik Abdul Kareem's conviction for conspiring to provide material support to the Islamic State (Count 5). According to the evidence at trial, Kareem paid for two of the guns used by Elton Simpson and Nadir Soofi, the two men who attacked a Muhammad cartoon contest in Garland, Texas, in 2015, and went shooting with them and taught them to maintain their weapons.

The disposition is unambiguous: the case goes back to the district court with instructions to enter a judgment of acquittal on that count and to resentence Kareem. His other convictions, including conspiracy to transport firearms with intent to commit murder, were affirmed in a separate memorandum issued the same day. He had been serving 360 months in prison.

The reasoning

For the majority (Judge Mendoza, joined by Judge Desai), ideological inspiration is not enough. The statute (18 U.S.C. § 2339B) requires proof of action under the terrorist organisation's "direction or control"; acting entirely independently to advance its goals is not, in the court's reading, a "service" to ISIS. Without evidence of that link, the count fails. As the majority puts it: "However heinous Kareem's conduct may be," the government needed to show more.

Judge Collins dissented on this point. In his view, answering ISIS's public call for attacks does count as providing a "service" to the organisation, and the evidence was sufficient to uphold the conviction.

You can think the majority's reading is too narrow, and Collins raises a serious question: in an age of online calls to terror, a "direction or control" requirement leaves a blind spot. That is exactly why the ruling deserves to be reported accurately.

How it was reported

Courthouse News ran the headline that the Ninth Circuit "grants new trial" to Kareem. That is wrong. The court ordered an acquittal on that count, which rules out a retrial on it. The difference matters: a new trial leaves the door open to another conviction; an acquittal shuts it.

The same piece describes the contest organisers as a "right-wing extremist group." The ruling uses no such term. The label is the reporter's, not the court's.

Our searches also found no coverage of the decision by AP, The New York Times or Fox News, despite its bearing on one of the ISIS-inspired attacks on U.S. soil.

Still unconfirmed

  • The length of the new sentence is not yet known.
  • Any appeal by the Justice Department (rehearing en banc or Supreme Court): no statement found.

Sources